The Butt Plugs Collection meets our unique industry-leading quality and performance standards. All items are backed by the Sexual Toys® 100% Satisfaction Guarantee!
70 of 870 products
-
Jet Annihilator Carbon Metallic Black Butt PlugVendor:Jet Annihilator Carbon Metallic Black Butt PlugBlush
- Regular price
-
$40.88 - Regular price
-
$60.00 - Sale price
-
$40.88
Quick view
-
Jet Stealth Carbon Metallic Black Butt PlugVendor:Jet Stealth Carbon Metallic Black Butt PlugJet Line
- Regular price
-
$14.88 - Regular price
-
$26.00 - Sale price
-
$14.88
Quick view
-
Blush B Yours Basic Anal Plug - BlueVendor:Blush B Yours Basic Anal Plug - BlueBlush
- Regular price
-
$6.88 - Regular price
-
$14.00 - Sale price
-
$6.88
Quick view
-
B Yours Eclipse Pleaser Small PinkVendor:B Yours Eclipse Pleaser Small PinkBlush
- Regular price
-
$6.88 - Regular price
-
$14.00 - Sale price
-
$6.88
Quick view
-
B Yours Eclipse Pleaser Medium PurpleVendor:B Yours Eclipse Pleaser Medium PurpleBlush
- Regular price
-
$7.88 - Regular price
-
$16.00 - Sale price
-
$7.88
Quick view
-
Jet Fuc Plug Carbon Metallic BlackVendor:Jet Fuc Plug Carbon Metallic BlackBlush
- Regular price
-
$40.88 - Regular price
-
$60.00 - Sale price
-
$40.88
Quick view
-
Jet Fierce Carbon Metallic BlackVendor:Jet Fierce Carbon Metallic BlackBlush
- Regular price
-
$41.88 - Regular price
-
$62.00 - Sale price
-
$41.88
Quick view
-
Blush B Yours Basic Anal Pleaser - BlueVendor:Blush B Yours Basic Anal Pleaser - BlueBlush
- Regular price
-
$11.88 - Regular price
-
$22.00 - Sale price
-
$11.88
Quick view
-
American Bombshell Shellshock - SmallVendor:American Bombshell Shellshock - SmallDoc Johnson
- Regular price
-
$41.88 - Regular price
-
$62.00 - Sale price
-
$41.88
Quick view
-
Fetish Fantasy Extreme Inflatable Sphincter StretchVendor:Fetish Fantasy Extreme Inflatable Sphincter StretchPipedream
- Regular price
-
$40.88 - Regular price
-
$60.00 - Sale price
-
$40.88
Quick view
-
Crystal Jellies Butt Plug Purple SmallVendor:Crystal Jellies Butt Plug Purple SmallDoc Johnson
- Regular price
-
$12.88 - Regular price
-
$23.00 - Sale price
-
$12.88
Quick view
-
Red Boy - Large Butt Plug RedVendor:Red Boy - Large Butt Plug RedDoc Johnson
- Regular price
-
$13.88 - Regular price
-
$24.00 - Sale price
-
$13.88
Quick view
-
Red Boy Medium Butt Plug RedVendor:Red Boy Medium Butt Plug RedDoc Johnson
- Regular price
-
$11.88 - Regular price
-
$22.00 - Sale price
-
$11.88
Quick view
-
Triple Ripple Medium Black Butt PlugVendor:Triple Ripple Medium Black Butt PlugBlush
- Regular price
-
$12.88 - Regular price
-
$22.00 - Sale price
-
$12.88
Quick view
-
Anal Plug Jelly PurpleVendor:Anal Plug Jelly PurpleDoc Johnson
- Regular price
-
$11.88 - Regular price
-
$21.00 - Sale price
-
$11.88
Quick view
-
B Yours Basic Anal Pleaser PinkVendor:B Yours Basic Anal Pleaser PinkBlush
- Regular price
-
$11.88 - Regular price
-
$22.00 - Sale price
-
$11.88
Quick view
-
Tush Trainer Intermediate Pink Butt PlugVendor:Tush Trainer Intermediate Pink Butt PlugCal Exotics
- Regular price
-
$18.88 - Regular price
-
$31.00 - Sale price
-
$18.88
Quick view
-
Jet Destructor Carbon Metallic Black Butt PlugVendor:Jet Destructor Carbon Metallic Black Butt PlugJet Line
- Regular price
-
$31.88 - Regular price
-
$48.00 - Sale price
-
$31.88
Quick view
-
Triple Ripple Butt Plug LargeVendor:Triple Ripple Butt Plug LargeThe Classics
- Regular price
-
$16.88 - Regular price
-
$28.00 - Sale price
-
$16.88
Quick view
-
American Bombshell - Fat Man - Gun MetalVendor:American Bombshell - Fat Man - Gun MetalAmerican Bombshell
- Regular price
-
$30.88 - Regular price
-
$46.00 - Sale price
-
$30.88
Quick view
-
Titanmen The Hollow Tunnel Plug ClearVendor:Titanmen The Hollow Tunnel Plug ClearTitanmen
- Regular price
-
$15.88 - Regular price
-
$26.00 - Sale price
-
$15.88
Quick view
-
Titanmen Intimidator Black PlugVendor:Titanmen Intimidator Black PlugDoc Johnson
- Regular price
-
$47.89 - Regular price
-
$74.00 - Sale price
-
$47.89
Quick view
-
Titanmen Ass Master Butt Plug 4.5 Inches BlackVendor:Titanmen Ass Master Butt Plug 4.5 Inches BlackDoc Johnson
- Regular price
-
$61.89 - Regular price
-
$92.00 - Sale price
-
$61.89
Quick view
-
Titanmen Master Tool #4 Black PlugVendor:Titanmen Master Tool #4 Black PlugDoc Johnson
- Regular price
-
$23.88 - Regular price
-
$37.00 - Sale price
-
$23.88
Quick view
-
Titanmen The Rumpy Black Butt PlugVendor:Titanmen The Rumpy Black Butt PlugDoc Johnson
- Regular price
-
$18.88 - Regular price
-
$30.00 - Sale price
-
$18.88
Quick view
-
Titanmen Anal Stretcher 6 Inches Expansion Plug BlackVendor:Titanmen Anal Stretcher 6 Inches Expansion Plug BlackDoc Johnson
- Regular price
-
$18.88 - Regular price
-
$30.00 - Sale price
-
$18.88
Quick view
-
Jet - Black Jack - Carbon Metallic BlackVendor:Jet - Black Jack - Carbon Metallic BlackBlush
- Regular price
-
$16.88 - Regular price
-
$28.00 - Sale price
-
$16.88
Quick view
-
Jet Bruiser Carbon Metallic Black Butt PlugVendor:Jet Bruiser Carbon Metallic Black Butt PlugBlush
- Regular price
-
$17.88 - Regular price
-
$30.00 - Sale price
-
$17.88
Quick view
-
Anal Adventures Basic Plug Kit - BlackVendor:Anal Adventures Basic Plug Kit - BlackBlush
- Regular price
-
$21.88 - Regular price
-
$34.00 - Sale price
-
$21.88
Quick view
-
American Bombshell - Little BoyVendor:American Bombshell - Little BoyAmerican Bombshell
- Regular price
-
$17.88 - Regular price
-
$29.00 - Sale price
-
$17.88
Quick view
-
American Bombshell B7 - TangoVendor:American Bombshell B7 - TangoAmerican Bombshell
- Regular price
-
$19.88 - Regular price
-
$32.00 - Sale price
-
$19.88
Quick view
-
American Bombshell Shellshock LargeVendor:American Bombshell Shellshock LargeAmerican Bombshell
- Regular price
-
$63.89 - Regular price
-
$95.00 - Sale price
-
$63.89
Quick view
-
Pretty Ends Butt Plug Medium 5.5 Inches BlueVendor:Pretty Ends Butt Plug Medium 5.5 Inches BlueSexual Toys®
- Regular price
-
$11.88 - Regular price
-
$21.00 - Sale price
-
$11.88
Quick view
-
Spectragel Anal StufferVendor:Spectragel Anal StufferSpectra Gels
- Regular price
-
$12.88 - Regular price
-
$22.00 - Sale price
-
$12.88
Quick view
-
Raging Hard-Ons Butt Plug LargeVendor:Raging Hard-Ons Butt Plug LargeDoc Johnson
- Regular price
-
$13.88 - Regular price
-
$24.00 - Sale price
-
$13.88
Quick view
-
Medium Pink Jelly Butt PlugVendor:Medium Pink Jelly Butt PlugDoc Johnson
- Regular price
-
$13.88 - Regular price
-
$24.00 - Sale price
-
$13.88
Quick view
-
Crystal Jellies Jelly Butt Plug Small - ClearVendor:Crystal Jellies Jelly Butt Plug Small - ClearDoc Johnson
- Regular price
-
$12.88 - Regular price
-
$23.00 - Sale price
-
$12.88
Quick view
-
Ignite Small Cock Plug Beige Butt PlugVendor:Ignite Small Cock Plug Beige Butt PlugIgnite
- Regular price
-
$8.88 - Regular price
-
$17.00 - Sale price
-
$8.88
Quick view
The Butt Plugs Collection features the industry's leading sexual toys and novelty product manufacturers. We appreciate your desire for a large selection and high quality. We ship these in-stock items multiple times per day for lightening fast order processing. Thank you for shopping with us, click the button below to return to the home page.